Analogy and Exemplary Reasoning in Legal Discourse
- 1 online resource (196 pages).
- Book collections on Project MUSE. .
Frontmatter -- Table of contents -- Introduction -- 1. Imitation and analogy / 2. Indefeasible analogical argument / 3. Is analogy a form of legal reasoning? / 4. Analogical reasoning and extensive interpretation / 5. Analogy and balancing / 6. Analogy and balancing / 7. Analogy and balancing once again / 8. Argument by analogy in the law / 9. Undoing damage by analogy / 10. Analogy in the strict liability rules in the Dutch Civil Code / Bibliography -- Index. Amaya, Amalia -- Brewer, Scott -- Brożek, Bartosz -- Canale, Damiano / Tuzet, Giovanni -- Duarte, David -- Brożek, Bartosz -- Duarte, David -- Golding, Martin -- Kaptein, Hendrik -- Velden, Bastiaan van der --
Open Access
This book brings together contributions from leading figures in legal studies on analogy and related forms of reasoning in the law. Analogical reasoning--which relies on the concept of two different things being in some way like each other--is hugely important not just in the practice of law, but it is nonetheless strongly contested. This volume raises key questions like: What is the logical, argumentative, rhetorical, or just heuristic force of analogy in law? Is analogy really different from extensive interpretation, reasoning by precedent and appeal to paradigm?